Bob Patterson's First Work on MDI
Photograph of Robert Patterson that
hangs in Jordan Pond House |
Patrons of the Jordan Pond House will
know the photograph: A gentleman in
his sixties surveys the dining room,
hands at rest on lapels in the manner of
18th–century portraits. Those who knew him
can imagine this composed man offering
advice in a calm voice on the right moss for
a garden recess, how to feather a paddle
stroke in wilderness waters, a fresh way for
morning light to flood a room–to–be, or a
path to compose the needs of town and park.
The man is Robert Whiteley Patterson,
known to many as a leading architect of
20th–century coastal Maine. Less known is
his earlier contribution—to composing
nature and design in our park.
Patterson was enabled by the Acadian
visionaries. Born in 1905, he was just four
years younger than the conserving collaboration
of Eliot and Dorr, and the Harvard
from which he graduated in 1927 was still
the University of President Eliot less than
twenty years after his retirement. Patterson
came to Mount Desert Island in 1934 in time
to participate in Superintendent Dorr’s last
full decade of park development when he
joined New Deal resources and private philanthropy.
John D. Rockefeller Jr., the principal
source of that philanthropy, was then at
work on his grand bequest of lands, roads,
and bridges when Patterson arrived. Patterson
would design and build for Rockefeller’s children,
and for many islanders for whom park
roads were and are a way to work.
From the same good New England soil as
Eliot and Dorr, Patterson was raised in modest
comfort in the well–wooded village of
Wayland, Massachusetts, only a short ride
from Boston. His father died when he was
two, but a strong mother and aunt filled some
of the loss, and older brothers guided him
through the woods and waters near his town,
nurturing the future conservationist. Soon
enough, the tall, young Noble and
Greenough man straight–arrowed through
academic and athletic achievement to
Harvard in 1923.
There Patterson found his professional passion
in architecture, returning to the Graduate
School of Design in 1932 to specialize in
landscape architecture. He had already found
personal happiness with Barbara Brown, also
of Wayland. They wed in 1931 when he was
26 and she 19, and it was she who first
brought him to Mount Desert and Acadia.
The couple enjoyed a summer stay in 1932
with her relatives who were second–generation
rusticators in Southwest Harbor.
The island drew him back. In January of
1934, in the depths of the Great
Depression—and into a howling blizzard—
the Pattersons and their baby daughter drove
north to Maine, where they made their home
for the next 54 years, save two away during
World War II. Soon employed on the staff of
the new Civilian Conservation Corps camp
in Ellsworth, Patterson was enlisted for island
projects, many within the expanding park
where the young designer’s skills were a
welcome resource for Benjamin Breeze, the
park’s landscape architect.
One of Patterson’s first assignments was
to conceive an expansion and integration of
the Beech Cliff and Beech Mountain trail system,
building on the achievements of the
Southwest Harbor Village Improvement
Association. A parking lot and short trail up
to the cliffs were roughed in by island men
employed by the New Deal CWA program
late in 1933, but heavy snows had halted
them. In the spring of 1934, Bob Patterson’s
CCC lads finished this work and built the
trail loop around the cliffs, working to his
design that “one of the most important
requirements in stone work here is that it
looks harmonious and unobtrusive in its surroundings
of beautifully lichened ledges.” The
29–year old designer wanted the Beech Cliff
loop trail to be “safe and passable, but nothing
more, leaving the route as unchanged as
possible.” It remains so after 75 years.
Young Patterson’s design aesthetic also
shone in the challenging Perpendicular Trail
up the rugged east side of Mansell, also begun
in 1934. “The requirements of the trail are
first scenic beauty, either in distant views or
nearby forest stand; second, an ultimate
objective point climaxing the hike; and third,
there must be embodied in the trail itself a
natural change of pace—for example, from
steep rock climbs to level moss or needle surfaced
walks.” The ultimate objective of his
design was achieved in full only in 2007,
when the Acadia trails crew finished the
upper section with an aesthetic worthy of
Patterson.
The Perpendicular Trail clearly engaged all
the skills of the young artist, who saw the
need for strength, delicacy, and design against
despoilers. In one section, “the problem [was]
one of securing substantial steps as security
against heaving by the ice and frost action,
or a rugged coping of a size defying movement
or dislodgement by any one or two individuals’
efforts.” In other sections, his attempt
would be to “soften and naturalize [the] rocky
sections by clothing ragged and bare surfaces
with moss and mats of rock fern, such as
grow for the most part throughout the talus
slope.” As the authors of Pathmakers would
observe more than 70 years later, in a telling
break from their usually austere style, “The
trail is one of the most highly constructed
on the island . . . [the] views are grand to the
southeast, but the stonework steals the show.”
By 1935, Bob Patterson had become the
full–time assistant to Ben Breeze at Acadia
National Park. From the beginning, he was
a man of vision, committed to conservation
and mindful of the frailty of the trails his CCC
crews created. As he would soon advise his
supervisors, there is a “’fundamental principle
[that] areas used by the public (unless
most carefully planned for several decades of
time), tend to destroy themselves for the particular
park purpose for which they are used.”
Did George B. Dorr hear the distinctive
voice of his designer? Documentation does
not confirm this, but since the Pattersons
rented a home on Livingston Road very near
the old Park Headquarters at Park and Lower
Main, it seems likely that the vigorous octogenarian
enjoyed good talks with this young
park employee, a Harvard man and proper
Bostonian who shared Dorr’s passion for
plants and lived just a few steps away.
Robert W. Patterson’s future, however, was
only a few steps more in another direction,
toward the shore at Reef Point Gardens, and
into history. His long professional association
with Beatrix Farrand and commitment to her
vision led to many commissions, and to his
essential roles in honoring the decisions of
Farrand’s final years, and saving the plants
of Reef Point for their lasting life at the Asticou
Azalea and Thuya Gardens, created by his
good friend Charles K. Savage.
The young Bob Patterson who came to
the portal of that future had already found an
island aesthetic while high on Acadian slopes,
directing young CCC men from across Maine.
Lessons learned working on the Beech Cliff
and Mansell trails as he began his decades
here helped guide the hand that gave us more
than 40 MDI houses, grand and modest, for
frugal townsmen, as well as Astors and
Rockefellers. The public service he began in
the park would lead to many of our amenities,
from wading pools and wharfs to landscaping
for schools and churches. The
thoughtful young park designer would
become a wise counsel for both park and
towns on the long path to recovery after the
1947 fire. The lover of things wild, drawn to
Acadia in his twenties, would found the
Maine Natural Resources Council, and further
conservation of our northern wilderness.
Friends of the Acadia that Bob Patterson
cherished might pause at his portrait on their
next visit to the Jordan Pond House, to reflect
on the unsigned works that the young artist
contributed at the beginning of his career on
our island.
JACK RUSSELL and his wife, Sandy Wilcox,
live at the north end of Echo Lake. He thanks
his neighbor Robert Whiteley Patterson, Jr.
(Lee) for generous guidance on this essay.
They are now, as once their fathers were, good
friends.
|