Schoodic's John Godfrey Moore

Picnic party on Schoodic Head, July 1923
Picnic party on Schoodic Head, July 1923

   Had John Godfrey Moore not died pre-maturely at age fifty-one, the wildly beautiful Schoodic Point might be a very different place today. As it happened, after Moore's death his heirs began spending their time away from their summer places in Winter Harbor and it was not until 1922, some twenty years after his death, that George Dorr was able to make arrangements to acquire Schoodic for the park. By then Moore's some-what younger second wife, Louise, had remarried and Moore's daughters were living in England, one married to Viscount Lee and the other, a spinster, living near her sister. The contact between Dorr and Louise Leeds was a casual one, made while both were having supper at the Jordan Pond House, but the result was that Dorr was able to set the wheels in motion for the eventual land acquisition. At the time of his death, however, Moore had vastly different plans for Schoodic Point.
   John Godfrey Moore came from modest beginnings. He was born in Steuben, Maine, the son of Captain Henry D. and Maria (Godfrey) Moore. The young Moore took whatever schooling he had at the local common schools, and spent one year at nearby Cherryfield Academy. When he was 18, he went to New York and entered into employment as a clerk in the lumber dealership of Thomas Mahew and Wilson Godfrey, his uncle. At age 21, Moore started his own lumber business and prospered almost immediately. In company with a partner named John Evans, he executed several important contracts with the War Department, including piers and breakwaters at Buffalo, New York, and Cleveland, Ohio, as well as dredging projects along the Delaware River.
   In 1880, he and Evans went into the fast-developing telegraph business, founding the Mutual Union Telegraph Company and constructing lines to rival Western Union. Their intentions were to lease their lines to businesses by day and to newspapers by night. Before all their plans could be realized Evans died and Moore, as the new president, led the company into one of the biggest competitive wars in the history of telegraphy. The outcome was that Western Union was forced to lease Mutual Union lines. Moore and his associates realized vast profits from the deal. Moore was subsequently elected to the Western Union board of directors.
   After living some years abroad, Moore returned to New York as the head of the brokerage firm Moore and Schley, also acquiring large interests in Chase Manhattan Bank and several railroads. After the panic of 1893, he invested $25,000 of his own money in a case to defeat a new federal income tax law. The Supreme Court ruled in his favor and the law was defeated, at least for the time being.
   All during his career, he maintained his interest in and loyalty to the rural section of Maine from which he sprang. He became involved in the plan to develop Grindstone Neck in Winter Harbor and built himself one of the largest cottages there, which he called "Far From the Wolf." He purchased hundreds of acres of forest and islands in the vicinity, including Schoodic Point. He built Schoodic Drive, the first carriage road on the point, which wound from his newly-built bridge at Frazer Creek, along the bold, rocky shores to the salt ponds and Devil's Anvil. His road also climbed to the summit of Schoodic Head, a favorite spot, reputedly, because from there he could see all the way to his native Steuben and beyond. He had plans to build a grand hotel at the summit, and supposedly had ideas for the further development of the rest of Schoodic. He died, however, before these plans could be brought to fruition. Apparently his heirs were not as enamored of the area as he was, although his daughter Faith did maintain a summer home on Grindstone for several years afterward.
   The day after Moore's death, an article appeared in the Bar Harbor Record quoting a previous interview with him concerning his acquisition of Schoodic Point and the islands and of the pleasure he realized from building the first substantial road on the point. He stated that he had acquired the land because of its beauty, noting that there was nothing he admired more than a mountain, "especially when an ocean goes with it." Also, he explained, he had enjoyed the experience of Yankee trading with the previous land owners, and he thought that it would be a good investment considering what was being developed in Bar Harbor at the time. The road, he said, was built for his own pleasure and convenience, but also as an object lesson in economy for the local authorities. He felt that they could repeat his successes in the public roads all over the area. Moore said, "[The road] is nine miles long and I enjoyed every foot of itŠ. It did me and my family as much good as a trip to Europe and didn't cost any more. Besides, it gave employment to a large number of people who need the money." While it may have seemed arrogant of him to assume that he could teach the locals how to build roads, any hard feelings the statement may have provoked was probably defused with his sincere efforts to create jobs and to aid the local economy.
   After Moore died on June 27, 1899, concurrent services were held in New York City and at St. Christopher's-by-the-Sea in Winter Harbor. Bedford Tracy, a young Winter Harbor attorney who was a local associate of Moore's, elaborately eulogized him at the Grindstone service and concluded with the words, "The fragrance of his acts of kindness perfumes his sepulcher, and he must live on, embalmed by our love and garlanded with our affection. The cold marble bears in mockery many a name forgotten but for the letters chiseled on its icy slab. It cannot be so with the name of John G. Moore, which is chiseled on the tablets of too many hearts to need the aid of marble or bronze to perpetuate it."
   Nevertheless, Acadia National Park has placed a bronze tablet in his memory at the overlook on Big Moose Island. Also in his honor, in 1937 the name of the road which runs from the village south to the bridge at Frazer's Creek was officially, albeit belatedly, changed by the people of Winter Harbor from Schoodic Street to the Moore Road.
Allan Smallidge is a native of Winter Harbor and a graduate of the University of Maine. After a career teaching high school English both in Maine and in Massachusetts public schools, he returned to Winter Harbor to serve as Town Manager for fourteen years, until retiring in 1998.
Summer 2005
entire issue in pdf format

Selected Articles
President's Column
Schoodic's John Godfrey Moore
Special Person: Julie Hall
Poem: Suspended
Purple Sandpipers in Coastal Maine
Poem: Waiting for the Maple to Leaf Out


Subscribe Now
Archive
Poetry Competition
download Acrobat Reader



Home · About Us ·Contact Us · How You Can Help · Journal · Projects · Volunteer